Skip to content
Green Market Network

Irish Unification Plebiscite Must Not Transform Into 'Another Brexit', Analysts Warn

A decade following the UK embarked on a hasty referendum that polarised the nation and unleashed turmoil, a caution is issued from beyond the Irish Sea: it might repeat.

The government and electorate entered unwittingly Brexit and the same could occur with a national vote on a united Ireland, initiating convulsions for which no one is prepared.

That conveys the caution from two respected journalists from both sides of the Irish border who have collaborated to scrutinise the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland exiting the UK to establish a fresh nation with the Republic of Ireland.

Political Establishments Not Ready

Fintan O’Toole and The Northern Ireland editor, have concluded that the government bodies in Ireland and Britain are extremely ill-prepared for a potentially tense and monumental referendum.

"The crucial insight of Brexit has gone unabsorbed, which is that stuff can emerge unexpectedly and can gain traction swiftly," the commentator stated. "I would suggest that the institutional structure of our archipelago remains highly fragile."

New Title Aims to Encourage Dialogue

The team have studied the political, economic and cultural arguments for any governmental shift in a publication, Examining Irish Unification, published by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.

They hope to provoke discussion on the topic with a roadshow of speaking events that will lead them to Westminster soon.

"What haunts everyone, or ought to concern every person, is the Brexit referendum of 2016," said the analyst.

"We do not want a national vote on a yes-no, vague proposition whose consequences have not been spelled out because then you land with an extremely divided society where those defeated are resistant to defeat and the victorious side don't know exactly what it is that they have gained."

Constitutional Provision

Under the Belfast Agreement, the Northern Ireland secretary of state should call a referendum on Irish unification if it seems probable that a most voters would vote in favour.

Sinn Féin and other nationalists argue such a time is looming, and a organisation named Ireland’s Future has built momentum, but both governments and pro-UK factions minimise the possibility, resulting in ambiguity when or if there will be a referendum.

Lack of Substantive Discussion

Partisan language supporting and opposing unification has hidden the absence of serious debate, noted the journalist.

"Many are for or against the idea but the detailed consideration which might go beyond that to achieve it is mostly absent. Much has occurred in scholarly circles but scarcely any elected officials or campaigners want to engage with even the basics. To illustrate, what sort of state would you want? Centralised? Decentralised?"

Publication's Method

In the volume, neither author supports unification or the status quo. They composes two essays that seek impartiality in laying out the argument for a united Ireland and the rationale against, assembling economic and social statistics, previous instances and constitutional models.

Debates range over national emblems, levies, healthcare systems, retirement funds, public liabilities and the risk of unionist unrest. The objective is to educate and stimulate dialogue.

"Considerable attention exists in the issue but there has not yet occurred a discussion," said the writer. "Dialogue indicates an acknowledgement of the notion that there could be valid points on each side."

Simultaneous Plebiscites

A referendum in Northern Ireland would simultaneously prompt one in the Republic of Ireland, where citizens claim they prefer unification but refuse paying higher taxes or introducing a new flag to acknowledge unionists' British identity.

"Authorities in Dublin must establish what the proposal from Irish nationalism is aside from just declaring: 'We desire a united Ireland and we welcome you'," stated the commentator.

Likelihood of Referendum

The journalist believes a national vote in his generation is possible and that it could happen unexpectedly. "It is possible just a mad or a poor or a incompetent secretary of state who says: 'We should proceed and get it out of the way.'"

Both nationalists and pro-UK supporters have credible, valid perspectives, he commented. "Somebody will win in this matter and the other side will in the end be defeated but all factions has possesses valuable insights to learn from the opposing positions."

Call for Broader Dialogue

Westminster must engage with the discussion, said the analyst. "This is about your state. It's a UK matter as much as it is an Irish matter."

About the author

Oscar Mason

Environmental journalist and advocate for sustainable lifestyles, exploring green innovations and ethical markets.

Green Market Network

Type to search articles.